Cookie Dough Creations offers oversized bakery-style cookie trays for events, parties, and gatherings across Naperville and surrounding suburbs. Each tray features our famous 4oz cookies, baked fresh in-house and arranged under a clear lid for a presentation-ready display. Available in trays of 12, 24, or custom quantities. Just great cookies, ready to serve.
A Cookie Tray from Cookie Dough Creations is the simplest way to bring crowd-pleasing desserts to any event. No frills, no decisions. Just our famous oversized 4oz cookies, baked fresh and arranged on a presentation-ready tray with a clear lid.
Every cookie is made in-house from the same family recipe we've used since 1994. At 4 ounces each, these are significantly larger than standard bakery cookies. It's the first thing customers notice when they open the tray.
Choose from our 4 signature flavors (Chocolate Chip, Frosted Sprinkle, M&M, and Peanut Butter) and mix and match in any combination. Trays are available in quantities of 12, 24, or custom amounts to fit your guest count.
All cookie trays require 24 hours' notice and are available for pickup at our downtown Naperville location on Chicago Ave.
Our 12-cookie tray is built for smaller gatherings. Team lunches, family dinners, classroom treats, or as a dessert addition to a larger spread.
What's Included:
Perfect for groups of 10 to 15 where you want a simple, impressive dessert without overthinking it.
24-Hour Advance Order Required | Pickup Only
Our 24-cookie tray is the go-to option for larger events. Office parties, birthday celebrations, graduation gatherings, and holiday spreads across Naperville.
What's Included:
This is our most popular cookie tray size. It serves 20 to 30 guests comfortably and looks impressive the moment it hits the table.
24-Hour Advance Order Required | Pickup Only
Need more than 24? Planning a wedding dessert table, a large corporate event, or a community gathering? We build custom cookie trays in any quantity to match your guest count.
How It Works:
We've catered events with 100+ guests using multiple cookie trays alongside our Party Boxes and cookie dough cups. Whatever the scale, we can make it work.
Our cookie trays are the easiest dessert option for events of all sizes. No slicing, no plating, no mess. Just grab a cookie and go. Here's what our customers order them for most.
A tray of oversized cookies is the easiest way to handle dessert at any birthday party. Kids love them, adults love them, and you don't need to worry about cutting, serving, or cleanup. Just set the tray down and let your guests help themselves.
Great for backyard birthdays, venue parties, and family celebrations in Naperville.
Cookie trays add a simple, crowd-pleasing dessert to any shower without competing with the rest of your spread. The presentation-ready tray with clear lid looks polished on any table, and the oversized cookies are easy for guests to grab between conversations.
A clean, no-fuss dessert option for showers throughout Naperville and DuPage County.
Graduation parties often mean larger guest lists — and our Party Boxes are built to serve a crowd comfortably. With oversized cookies and multiple cookie dough flavors, guests can mix and match without needing multiple dessert stations.
A Naperville favorite for high school and college graduation celebrations.
Cookie trays are our most popular corporate order. They're professional, easy to display in a break room or conference room, and everyone reaches for one. We work with local Naperville businesses on both one-time orders and recurring weekly or monthly deliveries for team meetings and client events.
No cutting, no plating, no cleanup. Just open and enjoy.
Holiday parties, family reunions, church events, school functions, engagement parties, neighborhood gatherings. A tray of oversized cookies works at every single one. When you need a dessert that's simple, crowd-pleasing, and requires zero effort, cookie trays are the answer.
Want cookies AND cookie dough? Check out our Party Boxes for the full Cookie Dough Creations experience.
Cookie trays are available in quantities of 12, 24, or custom amounts.
All orders require 24 hours' notice and are available for pickup at our downtown Naperville location.
Our cookie trays feature 4 signature flavors: Chocolate Chip, Frosted Sprinkle, M&M, and Peanut Butter. Each cookie is an oversized 4oz bakery-style cookie, baked fresh in-house. You can mix and match any combination of flavors on your tray.
Cookie trays are available in quantities of 12, 24, or custom amounts. A 12-cookie tray is great for smaller gatherings (10 to 15 guests). A 24-cookie tray comfortably serves 20 to 30 guests. For larger events, call us to build a custom order at any quantity.
We require a minimum of 24 hours' notice for all cookie tray orders. Every cookie is baked fresh to order, so advance notice ensures the freshest quality possible. Call for rush orders at (630) 369-4833.
All cookie tray orders are available for pickup only at our downtown Naperville location at 22 W Chicago Ave, Naperville, IL 60540. Every tray comes presentation-ready with a clear lid. Just pick it up and go.
Yes. Our cookie trays are fully customizable. You can choose any combination of Chocolate Chip, Frosted Sprinkle, M&M, and Peanut Butter cookies to build the perfect tray for your event.
Pricing varies based on your selection and quantity. Call us at (630) 369-4833 and we'll help you design the right cookie tray for your event and provide accurate pricing.
A Cookie Tray features just our oversized baked cookies. Simple, classic, crowd-pleasing. A Party Box includes both oversized cookies AND individual cups of our edible cookie dough, giving you the variety option with something for everyone. If you want the full Cookie Dough Creations experience, check out our Party Boxes. If you just want great cookies, a Cookie Tray is the move.
Yes. We partner with local Naperville businesses for recurring cookie tray orders including weekly team meetings, monthly employee appreciation, holiday parties, and more. Call (630) 369-4833 to set up a standing order.