Cookie Dough Creations builds custom cakes using your choice of premium ice cream and our famous edible cookie dough, layered on a crushed Oreo cookie crust. Every cake is made fresh to order at our downtown Naperville shop and comfortably serves 16 or more guests. Pick your flavors, place your order, and pick up a showstopper. $49.99 per cake.
Our cakes are not your typical birthday cake. Each one is built from scratch using three layers that you won't find at any other bakery in Naperville.
Layer 1: A crushed Oreo cookie crust base that holds everything together and adds crunch.
Layer 2: Your choice of premium ice cream from our selection of 11 flavors, including Vanilla, Chocolate, Cookie Dough, Mint Chip, Banana Pudding, and more.
Layer 3: A generous layer of our famous in-house edible cookie dough, made from the same family recipe we've used since 1994. Choose from 8 flavors including Chocolate Chip, M&M, Oreo, Cake Batter, Peanut Butter, Fudge Brownie, Brown Sugar, and S'mores.
The result is a rich, dense, one-of-a-kind dessert that combines ice cream and cookie dough in a way no other cake in Naperville can. Customers consistently tell us the same thing when they pick one up: "This cake is heavy." That's because it's packed with real ice cream and real cookie dough. No fillers, no shortcuts.
Every cake is fully customized to your taste.
Here's what you choose:
Cookie Dough Flavor (Pick 1 of 8):
• Chocolate Chip
• M&M
• Oreo
• Cake Batter
• Peanut Butter
• Fudge Brownie
• Brown Sugar
• S'mores
Ice Cream Flavor (pick 1 of 11):
• Vanilla
• Chocolate
• Strawberry
• Cookie Dough
• Oreo
• Superman
• Mint Chip
• Cappuccino Chip
• Pecan Praline
• Banana Pudding
• Moose Tracks
With 88 possible flavor combinations, your cake can be as classic or as creative as you want. Some of our most popular combos include Chocolate Chip dough with Vanilla ice cream, Oreo dough with Mint Chip ice cream, and Cake Batter dough with Cookie Dough ice cream.
Price: $49.99 | Serves 16+ guests | 24-hour advance order required | Pickup only
Every cake from Cookie Dough Creations is built to be a centerpiece. Here's what you should know before ordering:
Serves: 16 or more guests comfortably. These cakes are rich and dense, so portions go further than a standard sheet cake.
Decoration: We include a festive "Happy Birthday" sign with your cake at no extra charge. Custom writing is not available at this time.
Pickup: All cakes are available for pickup only at our downtown Naperville location at 22 W Chicago Ave. We recommend picking up as close to your event time as possible.
Transport: Keep the cake out of direct heat during transport. If your drive is longer than 30 minutes, we recommend placing the cake in a cooler to preserve its structure.
Allergens: All allergen information for each ice cream and cookie dough flavor is listed on our website. Include any concerns in the notes section of the order form and our team will take extra care in preparation.
Lead Time: 24-hour minimum advance order. Call (630) 369-4833 for rush orders.
Our ice cream cookie dough cakes are built for celebrations. Whether it's a milestone birthday or a graduation party, these cakes are the centerpiece your event deserves.
Our most popular cake occasion. Whether it's a kids' party or an adult milestone, a custom ice cream and cookie dough cake is a birthday centerpiece that guests remember. Let the birthday person pick their favorite dough and ice cream combo for a truly personal celebration.
The go-to birthday cake for families across Naperville.
Looking for a dessert that stands out at a shower? Our cakes offer a unique alternative to traditional bakery cakes. The combination of ice cream and cookie dough on an Oreo crust gives your guests something unexpected and memorable.
A showstopping dessert for showers throughout Naperville and DuPage County.
Celebrate the graduate with a cake that serves 16+ guests and tastes nothing like a store-bought sheet cake. Our cakes are rich, dense, and packed with flavor. Order multiple cakes for larger graduation parties or pair one with our Party Boxes or Cookie Trays for a full dessert spread.
A Naperville favorite for high school and college graduations.
Employee birthdays, team milestones, client appreciation events, and holiday parties. Our cakes bring something different to the office compared to the usual bakery order. At $49.99 and serving 16+ people, it's an affordable way to make any corporate event feel special.
A fun, memorable dessert option for Naperville businesses.
Anniversaries, engagement parties, holiday gatherings, family reunions, and yes, weddings. Our cakes work as a standalone dessert centerpiece or alongside our Party Boxes and Cookie Trays for a full dessert table. We've catered events with 100+ guests using multiple cakes and dessert trays.
Planning a bigger event?
Call us at (630) 369-4833 and we'll help you build the right dessert spread.
Please Refer to our Ice Cream Menu for Descriptions and Allergies
Cakes Comfortably serve 16+ People
Custom Made-to-order Ice Cream + Cookie Dough Cake $49.99
Our cakes are built with three layers: a crushed Oreo cookie crust base, a layer of premium ice cream (your choice of 11 flavors), and a generous layer of our famous in-house edible cookie dough (your choice of 8 flavors). Every cake is made fresh to order.
Our custom ice cream and cookie dough cakes are $49.99 each. Every cake is made to order with your choice of flavors.
Each cake comfortably serves 16 or more guests. The cakes are rich and dense, so portions go further than a standard sheet cake.
Keep the cake out of direct heat during transport. If your drive is longer than 30 minutes, we recommend placing the cake in a cooler to preserve its structure and keep it fresh.
All cake orders are available for pickup only at our downtown Naperville location at 22 W Chicago Ave, Naperville, IL 60540.
Some of our most popular combos include Chocolate Chip cookie dough with Vanilla ice cream, Oreo cookie dough with Mint Chip ice cream, and Cake Batter cookie dough with Cookie Dough ice cream. With 88 possible combinations, there's no wrong choice.
